The premium quality of ceremonial matcha is fundamentally reliant on the technique of shading (Ōishita Saibai). This process is crucial for maximizing the savory umami compound L-Theanine and achieving the vibrant green color. However, not all tea flushes (harvests) receive the same treatment. While the First Flush (Ichibancha) enjoys intensive, long-term shading, the subsequent Second and Third Flushes (Nibancha and Sanbancha) often receive minimal or no coverage. This difference is not arbitrary; it is rooted in the physiological needs of the tea plant, agricultural economics, and the diminishing return on quality.
The Energy Drain of Shading
The primary reason for reducing or eliminating shading on later flushes lies in the plant’s fundamental need for energy to survive and regenerate.
-
Photosynthesis Suppression: Shading works by blocking sunlight, which drastically suppresses photosynthesis—the process by which the plant generates the energy (sugars) needed for growth. While this stress forces the retention of L-Theanine, it comes at a cost.
-
The First Flush Advantage: The tea plant spends the entire winter in dormancy, accumulating a large reserve of starch and nutrients in its roots. When the First Flush buds emerge in spring, the plant utilizes these deep, stored reserves to grow new leaves, even under the stress of heavy shading. This allows the plant to maximize L-Theanine without immediately collapsing.
-
Post-Harvest Exhaustion: After the Ichibancha harvest in spring, the tea bush is significantly depleted of its stored energy. The sheer volume of nutrients and L-Theanine removed during the first harvest leaves the plant in a state of exhaustion. If the farmers were to immediately impose another period of heavy shading for the Second Flush, the plant would be unable to produce enough energy to sustain healthy growth.
Ensuring Plant Vigor and Future Yield
The decision to limit shading on Nibancha and Sanbancha is a necessary measure to protect the long-term health and commercial viability of the tea bush.
-
Preventing Damage: Imposing intense shade on an already depleted plant would severely weaken the entire bush, potentially causing the next set of buds to be stunted or failing to grow at all. This would compromise the Third Flush and, critically, the quality and quantity of the highly valuable First Flush the following spring.
-
Regrowth Necessity: The warmer temperatures during the summer months mean the plant needs to grow back quickly to maximize the total annual yield. Allowing the plant sufficient sunlight in between the first and second harvests is essential for the rapid recovery of its energy reserves and structure.
Economics and Quality Hierarchy
The quality hierarchy of the flushes also dictates the economic viability of intensive shading.
-
Diminishing Returns: The flavor potential of the Second and Third Flushes is inherently lower than the first due to environmental factors and nutrient depletion. The summer heat accelerates the plant’s metabolism, naturally favoring the production of catechins over L-Theanine, regardless of shading efforts.
-
Cost vs. Benefit: The labor and material costs associated with implementing and maintaining the shading apparatus are substantial. Since the Third Flush leaves will possess a naturally higher level of bitterness and lower L-Theanine content, the economic return on heavy shading is minimal. Farmers reserve their highest investment—both in terms of plant stress and labor cost—for the superior quality of the Ichibancha.
-
Intended Use: Later flushes, therefore, are mainly channeled into the Culinary Grade market, where the robust, slightly more astringent flavor is masked by other ingredients in lattes, sweets, and blends. For these uses, the expense and risk of heavy shading are unnecessary.
In conclusion, the practice of shading is strictly managed according to the tea plant's yearly cycle. While maximal shading is employed for the premium, umami-rich First Flush to achieve supreme quality, subsequent harvests must be treated gently. The reduced shading on Second and Third Flushes is a calculated decision rooted in agricultural science, essential for ensuring the plant's survival, guaranteeing future high yields, and balancing the costs against the inherent quality potential of the leaf at different times of the year.
