Matcha is defined by its ultra-fine, velvety texture, a characteristic achieved through a precise and meticulous grinding process. While modern technology offers various ways to pulverize the dried tea leaf (Tencha), traditional stone milling remains the gold standard for producing Ceremonial Grade matcha. The method of grinding is not merely mechanical; it is essential to preserving the tea's delicate flavor, color, and nutritional integrity.
The Superiority of Stone Milling (Ishiusu)
The traditional method involves grinding Tencha between two circular stones (Ishiusu). The top stone rotates slowly against the stationary bottom stone, pulverizing the leaf material into a micron-sized powder. This slow, deliberate process is what sets the final product apart.
1. Preservation of Flavor and Chemistry
The paramount advantage of stone milling is its ability to maintain a low grinding temperature.
-
Fact Base: Heat generated during high-speed grinding can cause thermal degradation. Matcha contains volatile aromatic compounds, delicate amino acids (like L-Theanine), and essential fatty acids. Excessive heat causes these components to oxidize or evaporate, dulling the vibrant taste and reducing the nutritional value.
-
Benefit: Stone mills rotate at an extremely slow speed (typically around 60 to 100 revolutions per minute). This minimizes frictional heat, ensuring the matcha retains its sweet, rich umami flavor and bright, fresh aroma.
2. Superior Texture and Foaming Quality
The slow, deliberate pressure of the stone mill creates an exceptionally uniform particle size, typically ranging from 5 to 10 micrometers.
-
Benefit: This ultra-fine particle size is key to matcha's signature quality: its velvety smooth mouthfeel and its ability to suspend perfectly in water. Crucially, it allows the matcha to be whisked into a thick, persistent foam (bubbly crema), which is essential for the traditional tea ceremony. Coarser particles result in a gritty texture and an inability to foam properly.
Stone Mill Capacity: The Price of Quality
The inherent slowness of the stone mill, while a quality advantage, is a major limiting factor in production volume and contributes directly to the high cost of Ceremonial Grade matcha.
-
Production Rate: A single traditional stone mill operates at an incredibly slow pace, capable of producing only a small amount of finished matcha per hour. The average yield is approximately 30 to 40 grams per hour (roughly 1 to 1.4 ounces).
-
Implication: To produce one kilogram of high-quality matcha requires an Ishiusu to run continuously for over 25 hours. This necessity for extended, slow grinding defines the premium nature of traditional matcha.
Alternative Grinding Methods: Speed vs. Quality
As matcha's global popularity has surged, faster, more cost-effective methods have been introduced to meet high demand, primarily for Culinary Grade products.
| Method | Mechanism | Speed/Volume | Impact on Quality | Typical Use |
| Stone Mill (Ishiusu) | Slow, rotating stone pressure | Very Slow (approx. 30-40 g/hour) | Excellent; preserves flavor and structure. Minimal heat generated. | Ceremonial Grade |
| Ball Mill | Agitating ceramics/steel balls in a rotating cylinder | Fast; high-volume production | Good; but generates heat. Flavor and color retention are moderate. | Premium Culinary Grade |
| Air Jet Mill | High-velocity air jets collide particles | Extremely Fast; high-volume | High heat and friction can damage fragile flavor compounds; less uniform particle size. | Industrial/Low-Grade Culinary |
Air Jet and Ball Milling
These industrial methods achieve speed and scale but compromise on the qualities prized in traditional matcha. They generate significantly more heat and friction, often producing a powder that is lighter in color, less vibrant in flavor, and quicker to oxidize. While sufficient for masking in lattes or baking (Culinary Grade), this matcha lacks the finesse required for drinking straight.
Conclusion
The distinction between stone-milled and industrially-milled matcha is a trade-off between speed and preservation. The traditional Ishiusu, with its laborious rate of approximately 30 to 40 grams per hour, guarantees the low temperature necessary to lock in the umami, bright color, and micro-fine texture that define true Ceremonial Grade matcha. While alternatives offer volume, they sacrifice the subtle chemical integrity that makes the experience of drinking high-quality matcha a meditative and distinctly superior one. The low yield of the stone mill is not a drawback, but a key component of its unparalleled quality.
